TV Shows Like American Nightmare

Loved American Nightmare? These 24 movies and shows share its DNA — surfaced by our semantic engine from theme, mood, cast and genre, then ranked by how closely they match. Every pick includes cast, ratings, trailers and streaming options.

American Murder: Gabby Petito 2025 ★ 7.2

Abducted in Plain Sight 2017 ★ 6.6

Unbelievable 2019 ★ 7.9

An American Crime 2007 ★ 7.3

Ordinary People 2018 ★ 7.6

Clickbait 2021 ★ 7.1

A Haunting 2005 ★ 7.5

High Crimes 2002 ★ 6.4

The Captive 2014 ★ 5.8

Elsewhere 2009 ★ 5.8

Caught 2015 ★ 5.4

American Nightmare 2002 ★ 5.0

Barbarian 2022 ★ 6.9

The Lovebirds 2020 ★ 6.1

And Soon the Darkness 2010 ★ 5.3

Unfamiliar 2026 ★ 7.0

Target 1985 ★ 5.9

Rendition 2007 ★ 6.4

Aftermath 2021 ★ 6.2

Under Suspicion 2000 ★ 6.1

Wander 2020 ★ 5.3

The Conspiracy 2012 ★ 6.0

Kill 'em All 2017 ★ 5.7

Henry's Crime 2010 ★ 5.8